The "Best" Random Wire Antenna
Lengths
Randon wire lengths you
should and should not use!
Updated 06-29-2012
The random
wire antenna is probably one of the least expensive, easiest and
cheapest HF antennas to use if you have a tuner and you want to
get the "most" out of a length of "random" wire without having to
pull out that calculator, doing the math, getting the center
insulator built or bought, running the feedline, and all the
rest that goes with putting up a more elaborate antenna.
All you
need for a random wire antenna is some wire, your tuner, one or more
supports up as high as you can get them to string the wire from the
supports to the tuner, at least one or two insulators and a
little time.
One single wire, no solder
connections, very simple.... all the way from the tuner to
the end support. That's it in a nutshell.....or
is it?
Many hams have tried till they are blue
in the face to install the random wire antenna that works on most;
if not all of the HF bands with terrible results.
Swr usually is all over the place and the
tuner will just not do it's job. You can get good loading and low
swr on sometimes 2 or 3 bands, but one or more of the bands
that you want, just will not cooperate with an swr that can be
adjusted with the "tuner".
So after much frustration..down it comes
and you go on to a totally different type of antenna....all that
time just wasted in your opinion.....until now!
We recently found some good information
about random wire lengths that you should and should
not use.
Jack,
VE3EED, hopefully has solved a major headache we all have when we
attempt to go thru the trial and error and frustration with getting
the random wire to work where WE want it to work.
He knew that in order for the tuner to
"see" a fairly low swr to work within it's range, that the
antenna had to be NOT A HALF WAVE ON ANY FREQUENCY that we
wanted to us, because a half wave will give us a very high impedance
and the resulting swr into a 50 ohm transmitter!
So Jack took most of one day, did the
math with the aid of his trusty calculator, several cups of coffee
and came up with...............................
In Jack's own words....
"Here's the word on random-wire
antennae."
Presented for your
consideration by Jack, VE3EED.
The table below
represents half wave lengths and multiples that you
DO NOT WANT TO USE!
You have to stay away from a
half wavelength on any frequency.
Therefore, we came up with the
following numbers to avoid (IN FEET):
These lengths in the table below are
the culprits that cause all of
the trouble when using random lengths.
| Frequency MHz |
1/2 Wave |
2nd Multiple |
3rd Multiple |
4th Multiple |
|
1.9 |
246 |
492 |
738 |
984 |
|
3.8 |
123 |
246 |
369 |
492 |
|
7.2 |
65 |
130 |
195 |
260 |
|
10.1 |
46 |
92 |
138 |
184 |
|
14.2 |
33 |
66 |
99 |
132 |
|
18.1 |
26 |
52 |
78 |
104 |
|
21.3 |
22 |
44 |
66 |
88 |
|
24.9 |
19 |
38 |
57 |
76 |
|
28.5 |
16 |
32 |
48 |
64 |
So those are the
numbers above that we have to stay as far away from as possible
when building a long-wire antenna.
Here they are in
order:
REVISED: 16 19 22 26
32 33 38 44 46 48 52 64 65 66 76 78 80 88 92 95 96 99 104 110 112
114 123 128 130 132 133 138 144 152 154 156 160 165 171 176 182 184
190 192 195 198 208 209 220 224 228 230 231 234 240 242 246 247 256
260 264 266 272 276 285 286 288 297 304 308 312 320 322 323 325 330
336 338 342 352 361 363 364 366 368 369 374 380 384 390 396 399 400
414 416 418 429 432 437 440 442 448 455 456 460 462 464 468 475 480
484 494 495 496.
Some of these numbers are
too close to squeeze in between them.
Here are the final numbers (in my opinion) in green below that would be good for a long-wire
antenna: (You may want to make a note
of them)
REVISED:
29 35.5 41 58 71 84 107
119 148 203 347 407 423
REVISION NOTE: We had a note from James,
KB5YN, pointing out that one of my so-called GOOD numbers was 220
feet. That is the 10th multiple of a half wave on 15 meters. Well, I
didn't think it would make any difference at that many multiples.
However, the radio didn't tune up very well on 15 meters.
So,
having nothing better to do one day, I re-did the calculations going
out to 500 feet. That meant calculating all the way to 32 multiples
of a half wave on 10 meters. I won't bore you with all that so the
first portion of this still only shows up to the 4th multiple. There
are so many new frequencies to stay away from, that it gets pretty
tricky for the longer wires. However, the list has been revised and
is good for wires as long as 500 feet.
73.... JACK, VE3EED
=======================
More on Random Wire Lengths
from Mike, AB3AP (06-29-2012)
Hello
everyone!
I was surfing around
Hamuniverse.com and found thIs page on random wire
antennas:
which got me thinking. Jack,
VE3EED, used center frequencies of the bands described in the
article above, and I thought it'd be nice to use band edges.
I wrote a small C
program that does just what Jack did, but I used the band
edges. Because I'm more visually oriented I then plotted the
many overlapping "red zones" and ended up with the page
at:
http://udel.edu/~mm/ham/randomWire/
I plotted the results for the U.S. CW band edges for
use with my 4 band Elecraft K1 qrp rig.
You will note that when comparing my
results with VE3EED that some of the results are a bit
different.
Just an FYI that I thought you might be
interested in.
73,
Mike ab3ap
Editors note: Many
thanks to Jack, VE3EED and Mike, AB3AP for sharing their math
and computer skills with us.
Hopefully these random wire
length calculations will help us all make this "easy" antenna work
better!
(Also note that here may be instances where the
suggested lengths may not work exactly due to the many
variables in the surroundings of the antenna, wire length
variances, your tuner, it's height above ground, it's
construction, etc. Just add or subtract as needed a little at a
time to get the best compromise. (The
numbers above are a great start, thanks to Jack and Mike!)
Note that Jack, VE3EED, does not have a published email address nor
website at this time.
Also check out
AB3AP'S website
and say thanks for sharing his skills.
They just saved you and I loads of time and
frustration.
N4UJW

|
Uniden 4 Inch Communications Speaker: 4"
Plastic Cone Impedance: 8 Ohms Maximum Power: 12
Watts Wire: 10 ft. cord with , AWG 18 Plug Type: 1/8"
or 3.5mm Plug Frequency Response: 500Hz-5KHz
(Tailored to voice frequencies) Includes
ratchet type mounting bracket & hardware
| Get
it Here! |
