|
LinkSys Routers and other
brands known to cause Interference to Ham
Radio Equipment Another plague for the
Ham Bands? Updates added
09-11-2012 This page contains brands and model numbers of
routers and other associated computer equipment known to
cause interference (RFI) to ham radio equipment and
possible cures for the problem.
(We are also working on a
list of computer related equipment including routers
that DO NOT CAUSE INTERFERENCE (RFI) to Amateur "ham
radio".) Your help is needed in sending us the brands and model
numbers of your computer equipment that DOES or DOES NOT
INTERFERE with your ham radio equipment. See bottom of
article for details we need. Please share your experience with
other hams worldwide.)
Information And A Cure for RFI/EMI from LinkSys
Routers and Their Products to Ham Radio?
MAYBE!
Multitudes of Ham Radio
operators are reporting in various forums, interference in varying
degrees from none, or minor, to MAJOR disruption to Ham Radio Bands
from LinkSys products of all types! Hams worldwide are having
problems associated with LinkSys products.
The purpose of this page is NOT to
downgrade or bash any manufacturer or product line....only to report
what others have said and done about the known interference problems
specific to the Ham Radio bands and the LinkSys products.
There may be other brands causing interference also.
Just a little FYI on the noisy
wireless router problems causing interference to Ham Bands.
Apparently this is a known issue with many Linksys routers and other
products from LinkSys whether they are wireless or not and has been
ongoing for a long time.
We will attempt to give you
information, some known models causing trouble, links, sources of
discussion, tips, and hopefully at least one
cure for Linksys product interference to the Ham Bands. There
are other sources on the internet concerning these problems but we
will give you some of the more popular ones. You can do a search and
find lots more.
More about the
problem.....
Some Hams are of the opinion
that the whole bag of Linksys models is involved to one degree or
another and that LinkSys knows about the problem but are not very
helpful most of the time except in rare instances. Usually the
support people just state that they are compliant with the FCC rules
and regs and drop the subject!
One
interesting question is how did they ever get type approval if they
are so compliant in causing interference to a Licensed
Service? Question unanswered as of this
writing!
Maybe LinkSys has the correct
answer!
Here are some
statements taken from various sources from Ham radio operators
concerning LinkSys products:
"It seems that all LinkSys
products have been produced with absolutely no shielding or RF
bypassing of any kind and with total disregard to interference,
RFI/EMI, caused to any other device."
"Linksys products have got to
be the worst on the market."
"SOME MODELS CAN BE
HACKED FOR INCREASED
POWER"
"My 2 meter rig is now happy
that LinkSys junk is gone."
"Frankly, I think these things
are messier than a spark gap transmitter!"
"These routers have also been
known to shut down adjacent networks, cordless phones, hf rigs,
pagers, baby monitors... you name it."
"There's a ton of pages online
about how it creates havoc on Amateur
Frequencies."
"Pure hash caused by
trash"
"Absolute Junk.....put it where it belongs....in the
trash.! "
"Disconnect it
from power......problems are gone!" Editors
note...this one says it all!
"Try shielding the
cables...may help some."
"I will never by another
LinkSys product again."
"I have a LinkSys model DI-524 router. With
power on, the router is breaking squelch on my 2m receiver
over 30 feet away. This is with the squelch full clockwise
and scanning is out of the question. With the router off,
the Yaesu 7800 is performing as advertised."
"The 624 is
history as soon as I can get a replacement."
And on and on.
What models are
involved?
According to our research on
the web using various forums, input from emails, bulletin boards,
etc, as sources, the LinkSys models mentioned below are the
worst offenders that create RFI/EMI to Amateur Radio Bands or
frequencies. If you have a model listed below, your results may be
different. Please report any rfi issues you may or may not have
if you use one of the listed models below......
Linksys Models Reported To Be RFI
Producers ....(including other
LinkSys products)..... this list is not all
inclusive..there may be others: (send use the brands and model
numbers)
Linksys Model WRT110 (info by
Larry Mann KD0BLL)----Mine has made 147.585Mhz unusable on 2 meters.
LINKSYS SRW208P PoE
Switch - Submitted by Dan, 2e0dpk (whooshing noise hf thru 6
meters)
BEFSR41
wireless-g router
"G" router + WAP
BEFSR11
WRT54G Update....Models in
Europe may not be problems ( "CE" marked according to Roger
MW0IDX K3IDX)...thanks to Roger!
WRTS54GS "I have a linksys router WRTS54GS. It is
"CE" marked and should meet a minimum requirement when it comes to
RFI. It does not. It is impossible to use the 6 meter band
when this router is on. And i have measured that it radiates form
around 21 mhz and up to around 300 mhz. Some of the noise is even
in the spectrum used my emergency services. This router is going in
the garbage!" LB5KE Norway
10/100 hub from Linksys (Model EFAH05W)
BEFSR1
BEFW11S4
Other
Brands Reported To Cause RFI to the ham bands:
Netgear DG834 (See update and fix
below by Bob,
G4CPV)
Netgear WNR2000 N300 series. 6
meters is trashed at my station. unbelievable bad noise at regular
intervals. Netgear WNR 2000 UPDATE
02-19-2012 Netgear WNR 2000 (From
KF5OBM)---- I was getting interference on 147.160 MHz from my Netgear
WNR 2000. The tip from VE3VDC was helpfull. I took the cat 5
cable from the router to the dsl modem and coiled it around a form 2
5/8" diameter (first thing I could find to wrap around).
That fixed the symptoms. It did not seem to be radiating from
anywhere else. Dan KF5OBM
NetGear Model FS524S 24 Port Router
(N0YFE)
D-524 Router (Note, this is not a
LinkSys product but was reported as a noise
producer)
D-Link, Model DI-624
ver. E1. 4 ports & 108 G wireless..... (Also not a LinkSys
product but was reported as a noise producer)
Hash on 2 meters for 3 to 4 hundred feet
away! D-Link 4300
D-link DIR-601 - Puts out
RFI on the 2 meter band. 146.910 is unusable for
some reason. Unpluging the router kills the rfi. The RFI
covers about 1500 sq. feet due to living in a Faraday cage
IE mobile home. I have also found that this router causes problems
with cell phones within 1 foot of the device. 73, Benjamin A. Straw
- KC9UNS
Update added by
Keith Thomas 09-11-2012
WB6ANP Netgear fs-108 8 port switch produces s9 noise on 14.270 area
as well as others. Net gear ndr-3400 v2 produces s5 noise on the
same band.
Send us your
brands and model numbers that cause RFI to your ham equipment
n4ujw AT
hamuniverse.com
Brands and model
numbers of routers, switches, etc reported to be OK,
FINE or NO interference noted to ham radio
equipment
Linksys SD2005 5 Port Switch (submitted by Dan,
2e0dpk) Netgear WNR3500L (reported to work fine on transmit and
receive) WNDR3400 Cradelpoint MBR900
Linksys WRT300N - No problems with rfi on radios or
radios causing problems with it. I use a Yaesu
ft-8800 and Yaesu FT-450AT Henry D.
Akin
AJ4PM
Send us your brand and model number that
DOES NOT cause rfi to your ham
equipment. n4ujw AT
hamuniverse.com
NOW ONE (CURE)......HOPEFULLY
from VE3VDC!
Taken from one of the
forums and referring to a wireless LinkSys router courtesy of
VE3VDC:
"When I called their support
line they not only knew all about it, they knew exactly who to put
me on with for advice.
Their support line is at
1-800-326-7114.
The problem is that the cat5
cables radiate the ethernet switching hash from inside the router."
(Editors Note...the keywords here are
{INSIDE THE ROUTER}....THE
SOURCE!)
The third harmonics land on
mid-VHF frequencies.
Basically they
suggested:
1) Set all NIC cards to 10
mbps.
2) Coil up extra cable length
on a "three finger" form and tape.
3) Disable unused ports.
4) Make certain all connectors
are clean and in good condition.
5) Keep the router at least 6
inches from metal objects.
6) Disconnect unused
cables.
This seems
to have worked.
No more washing machine sound
every few Khz all across 2 meters... at least for now. Time will
tell if this is a permanent solution. (fingers crossed) Source of
these tips...VE3VDC See his excellent article "RFI From Computer
Networks" here.
Another helpful hint....replace the wall wart
power supply with another brand with the same voltage and current
specs...many switching type power supplies are the source of rfi!
Watch that polarity!
Some other good sources,
forums, comments, etc concerning the problem with LinkSys products
and Ham Radio: Note, The eham.net
links below may require some rather long drawn out reading and
sorting time to wade thru all the QRM in the
articles.
http://www.eham.net/articles/8302
http://www.eham.net/forums/RFI/361
But it doesn't end there...
There's lots more on the internet!
SOME TIPS IN TRACKING DOWN SOURCES OF RFI IN THE
SHACK.
These tips may help in
locating severe noise sources to 2 meters and bands above that are
suspected of coming from your radio or computer equipment.
If the source strength is intense and fundamental frequency is low
enough, this could be the source of all your ham band problems. Also
see tips for HF below.
Tips for HF/VHF
and above: Here is a handy method of locating many noise sources
on the HF/vhf ham bands. Using a 2
meter handheld, adjust it to an unused frequency. Leave the "Rubber
Duckie" antenna attached. (Note that you may also use a portable
shortwave receiver tuned to the respective hf band with an external
"loop" probe setup as described below.)
Stand back several feet from
the suspected device or if needed in another room or location if the
white noise "floor" is too strong.
Adjust the squelch (on
vhf transceivers) just to the point that the white noise
stops if possible. If it does not, then you will have to remove the
antenna and get much closer to the suspect device. On portable
shortwave receivers without squelch, tune as needed for a "quiet" hf
frequency in the band you have rfi on.
Now move the handheld or
portable receiver around or near each and every piece of equipment
in your station that is near your router or associated cables. This
includes it's power supply, wall wart, interconnecting
cables, etc.
If the squelch breaks and
or noise poors from the receiver when you are very
close, then you have pin pointed the suspect device!
Now remove the antenna from the
handheld remembering the device, cable, etc, that caused the squelch
to break!
After you have removed the
antenna, move the antenna connector end of the handheld
toward the device.......the noise should increase and break the
squelch even higher as you get closer with the handheld if this
is the source of the noise to 2 meters. (When you removed the
antenna, you greatly decrease the "sensitivity" of the handheld.
This helps in pinpointing the exact source.)
If your handheld or
portable radio has a signal level meter, (S Meter), this will
aid in tracking down the source with more accuracy than listening to
the noise coming from the speaker. The stronger the reading, the
closer you are. With the antenna disconnected, you will have to be
very close to the suspected device to detect any rfi coming from
it.
Now leaving the handheld or
receiver probe in the same position (don't move it), remove all
cables from the suspect device except the power to the
unit.
If the noise stops or gets
much weaker and you hear no rfi at or near the power supply (the
wall wart)...one of more cables are most likely radiating trash rf
from INSIDE THE DEVICE! Don't forget the cables going to the
computer. Check them too. Your computer and associated devices,
cables, etc may also be adding to your problem or could be the
culprit!
If you remove the
power to the device and all noise stops.....you have found your
source!
BEST Solution.....If it is a
LinkSys device.......remove it from service and get another well
known brand in a metal case with shielded cables if possible
with known good shielding all around! Simple as
that.
Don't spend good money on
extra shielded cables, ferrites, etc and just wasting your
time....of course this is up to you.
Troubleshooting and locating RFI on the HF
Bands.
Use a short length of coax
connected to the antenna input of your HF rig, portable receiver or
handleld HT, with a very small "Sniffer or Probe" loop attached
to the other end. In other words, build yourself a very small loop,
about 1 or 2 inches in diameter, fed with 50 ohm coax leading
to your receiver's antenna input......Don't key
your transmitter while the loop is used for obvious
reasons!!!!!!
You will use the Hf receiver
or portable radio to help locate the suspected noisy device
just like in the 2 meter procedure above using the "Sniffer" loop on
the end of the coax. Make it long enough to reach all devices in
your station while listening to your receiver's audio. You may also
want to use someone to watch the S meter also for maximum deflection
or bars.
You may need to use
attenuation and or RF gain to reduce your receiver sensitivity
during this procedure. You want to have the least sensitivity the
closer you get to the source of the noise to aid in pin pointing
it.
Check all bands and
frequencies or the band that you are having the noise on by watching
the S meter and listening to the audio from the receiver. Hopefully
you will find the culprit.
Remember...the most simple thing to do in finding
the culprit is to disconnect the power
from each suspected device and if the noise stops.....you have
located the source! Then troubleshoot further. Don't just turn
it off....disconnect the AC power at the wall outlet! Some devices
are still 'on' when turned "off"!
Update 07-25-2011 from Bob, G4CPV
Netgear DG834 rfi noise
and a fix! At the shack here I have a Netgear
DG834 which is a 4 port ADSL router. This was emitting some hash
around 3.68MHz at 20dB over 9 and also at some other frequencies
around 4MHz and above. Using your suggested technique of a small
loop on the aerial lead I wound about 5 turns around a pen and used
it to sniff the source.
The router is fed from a 15v AC wall
wart and is rectified in the router. The noise was very strong
around the transformer and also from the back of the router where
the power feed was. Opening the case, the PSU was standard
ie bridge rectifier with a 2200uF smoothing cap. Unfortunately this
cap was manufactured by Teapo and from previous experience of
computers, monitors and PSU's these caps are
useless. The cap was changed and also a 0.2uF cap
placed in parallel with it. Once done the noise completely
disappeared! The odd thing is the Teapo cap was measured and
appeared absolutely fine both in value and ESR but on changing the
scope showed a vast reduction in hash and even more so when the
0.2uF was added. I did previously try a few turns on a toroid
which reduced the hash somewhat but didn't need it at all
afterwards.
Flushed with success I am now investigating a
lower strength noise which is across all the low frequency bands and
it's looking like it might be a Netgear switch.
73's Bob G4CPV -- Bob Fisk
Good luck
______________________________________________
Some comments from the UK!
11-05-2011
Extract from article
above:
"Usually the support
people just state that they are compliant with the FCC rules and
regs and drop the subject!
One interesting question is
how did they ever get type approval if they are so compliant in
causing interference to a Licensed Service? Question unanswered
as of this writing!"
"In the UK, it is
generally thought that certification of compliance with EEC
regulations, concerning electronic devices and RFI issues
is, generally worthless.
A manufacturer
supplies test models and is given a certificate of compliance. This
however only means that the supplied model and design are compliant
at the test. If then the manufacturer changes the construction,
componets or worse, a third party is contracted to make the units,
then that third party decides it can save money by ommiting
components like filter capacitors and these units are 'imported'
from shady origins lets say..then the games is, as they say, well
and trully over!
In the UK there are
literally thousands upon thousands of dark imports coming on to the
market because of purchases through online Retailers and Auction
sellers. This is a major source of RFI problems.
Policing of these
devices and so called officially certified units is non
existant."
Regards
John Edwards
GM7NVA
More RFI Tips and
Tricks....click here!.
Notes
from the Editor:
You will notice in the
response from LinkSys tech support to VE3VDC above, that they
AKNOWLEDGED THAT THEY HAVE THE PROBLEM with the particular model
listed!
We would like to thank L D
Blake, VE3VDC for informing us of this problem concerning LinkSys
products and the Amateur Bands and inspiring us to produce this
article. We usually do not report on concerns such as this but
due to the severe nature of the problems with LinkSys and other
brands and RFI on the Amateur Radio Bands, we hopefully can inform
more people about what they may be getting into if they use LinkSys
products or other brands in or near Amateur Radio
Stations......
Use these listings
with caution. They are reported here in good faith
but your experience may be different depending on your operating
conditions and radio equipment setup.
SEND US YOUR INPUT! DETAILS
NEEDED. If YOU have any valuable input to
this article pertaining to other models of LinkSys products or
other brands and models interfering
with Ham bands and/or known cures, please email us
with the exact models and description if possible of the
interference and cure if known. Please do not duplicate models and
brands already listed.
On this page
we are attempting to compile a list of brands and model numbers of
your COMPUTER equipment that DOES OR DOES NOT
INTERFERE with ham radio equipment! Email your info to
n4ujw at
hamuniverse.com. Please include any or all
details that may help others. The best will be edited for posting
here.
You may notice the Google ads
on the left side of the page with LinkSys advertising.....we are not
responsible for the Google ad content. They are sorted by
Google as related to the content on this page. I doubt
that any of you would be interested anyway in buying LinkSys
products if you read this complete article and do your research
unless you know for sure it does not interfere with you! If you are still interested in LinkSys...then the
choice is yours.
73 N4UJW
Hamuniverse.com {n4ujw at
hamuniverse.com} |